• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

The Cold Wire

  • Home
  • Sports News
  • NFL
    • Arizona Cardinals
    • Atlanta Falcons
    • Baltimore Ravens
    • Buffalo Bills
    • Carolina Panthers
    • Chicago Bears
    • Cincinnati Bengals
    • Cleveland Browns
    • Dallas Cowboys
    • Denver Broncos
    • Detroit Lions
    • Green Bay Packers
    • Houston Texans
    • Indianapolis Colts
    • Jacksonville Jaguars
    • Kansas City Chiefs
    • Las Vegas Raiders
    • Los Angeles Chargers
    • Los Angeles Rams
    • Miami Dolphins
    • Minnesota Vikings
    • New England Patriots
    • New Orleans Saints
    • New York Giants
    • New York Jets
    • Philadelphia Eagles
    • Pittsburgh Steelers
    • San Francisco 49ers
    • Seattle Seahawks
    • Tampa Bay Buccaneers
    • Tennessee Titans
    • Washington Commanders
  • MLB
    • Arizona Diamondbacks
    • Atlanta Braves
    • Baltimore Orioles
    • Boston Red Sox
    • Chicago Cubs
    • Chicago White Sox
    • Cincinnati Reds
    • Cleveland Guardians
    • Colorado Rockies
    • Detroit Tigers
    • Houston Astros
    • Kansas City Royals
    • Los Angeles Angels
    • Los Angeles Dodgers
    • Miami Marlins
    • Milwaukee Brewers
    • Minnesota Twins
    • New York Mets
    • New York Yankees
    • Oakland Athletics
    • Philadelphia Phillies
    • Pittsburgh Pirates
    • San Diego Padres
    • San Francisco Giants
    • Seattle Mariners
    • St. Louis Cardinals
    • Tampa Bay Rays
    • Texas Rangers
    • Toronto Blue Jays
    • Washington Nationals
  • NBA
    • Atlanta Hawks
    • Boston Celtics
    • Brooklyn Nets
    • Charlotte Hornets
    • Chicago Bulls
    • Cleveland Cavaliers
    • Dallas Mavericks
    • Denver Nuggets
    • Detroit Pistons
    • Golden State Warriors
    • Houston Rockets
    • Indiana Pacers
    • Los Angeles Clippers
    • Los Angeles Lakers
    • Memphis Grizzlies
    • Miami Heat
    • Milwaukee Bucks
    • Minnesota Timberwolves
    • New Orleans Pelicans
    • New York Knicks
    • Oklahoma City Thunder
    • Orlando Magic
    • Philadelphia 76ers
    • Phoenix Suns
    • Portland Trailblazers
    • Sacramento Kings
    • San Antonio Spurs
    • Toronto Raptors
    • Utah Jazz
    • Washington Wizards
  • Entertainment
  • About

The Cold Wire

Breaking News, Sports, Entertainment, TV, Tech ...

  • Home
  • Sports News
  • NFL
    • Arizona Cardinals
    • Atlanta Falcons
    • Baltimore Ravens
    • Buffalo Bills
    • Carolina Panthers
    • Chicago Bears
    • Cincinnati Bengals
    • Cleveland Browns
    • Dallas Cowboys
    • Denver Broncos
    • Detroit Lions
    • Green Bay Packers
    • Houston Texans
    • Indianapolis Colts
    • Jacksonville Jaguars
    • Kansas City Chiefs
    • Las Vegas Raiders
    • Los Angeles Chargers
    • Los Angeles Rams
    • Miami Dolphins
    • Minnesota Vikings
    • New England Patriots
    • New Orleans Saints
    • New York Giants
    • New York Jets
    • Philadelphia Eagles
    • Pittsburgh Steelers
    • San Francisco 49ers
    • Seattle Seahawks
    • Tampa Bay Buccaneers
    • Tennessee Titans
    • Washington Commanders
  • MLB
    • Arizona Diamondbacks
    • Atlanta Braves
    • Baltimore Orioles
    • Boston Red Sox
    • Chicago Cubs
    • Chicago White Sox
    • Cincinnati Reds
    • Cleveland Guardians
    • Colorado Rockies
    • Detroit Tigers
    • Houston Astros
    • Kansas City Royals
    • Los Angeles Angels
    • Los Angeles Dodgers
    • Miami Marlins
    • Milwaukee Brewers
    • Minnesota Twins
    • New York Mets
    • New York Yankees
    • Oakland Athletics
    • Philadelphia Phillies
    • Pittsburgh Pirates
    • San Diego Padres
    • San Francisco Giants
    • Seattle Mariners
    • St. Louis Cardinals
    • Tampa Bay Rays
    • Texas Rangers
    • Toronto Blue Jays
    • Washington Nationals
  • NBA
    • Atlanta Hawks
    • Boston Celtics
    • Brooklyn Nets
    • Charlotte Hornets
    • Chicago Bulls
    • Cleveland Cavaliers
    • Dallas Mavericks
    • Denver Nuggets
    • Detroit Pistons
    • Golden State Warriors
    • Houston Rockets
    • Indiana Pacers
    • Los Angeles Clippers
    • Los Angeles Lakers
    • Memphis Grizzlies
    • Miami Heat
    • Milwaukee Bucks
    • Minnesota Timberwolves
    • New Orleans Pelicans
    • New York Knicks
    • Oklahoma City Thunder
    • Orlando Magic
    • Philadelphia 76ers
    • Phoenix Suns
    • Portland Trailblazers
    • Sacramento Kings
    • San Antonio Spurs
    • Toronto Raptors
    • Utah Jazz
    • Washington Wizards
  • Entertainment
  • About
You are here: Home / Sports / MLB / Ranking The Top 3 Most Overrated Players In MLB

Ranking The Top 3 Most Overrated Players In MLB

June 4, 2021
By Sam Leweck
@samleweck
Leave a Comment
Follow Sam Leweck on Google News Follow Us

San Diego Padres first baseman Eric Hosmer (30) waves from first base in the bottom of the third inning during the baseball game between the San Diego Padres and Houston Astros on May 30, 2021 at Minute Maid Park in Houston, Texas.
(Photo by Leslie Plaza Johnson/Icon Sportswire)

 

The best way to evaluate MLB talent differs depending on who you ask.

While the eye test might matter most to one person, cold hard data might be the end-all-be-all for someone else.

Subjectivity is a major factor which often leads to disagreements and controversial takes.

We’re going to be ranking the three most overrated players in baseball today, but there are no guarantees that you will like what you see.

 

3. Joc Pederson

Joc Pederson has always been a fan favorite, but his numbers don’t exactly explain why.

The 29-year-old is currently in the midst of his first season with the Chicago Cubs after spending seven years with the Los Angeles Dodgers.

Pederson is capable of providing some pop in any lineup, as he has four 25-plus home run seasons to his credit.

Beyond that, however, Pederson doesn’t bring a whole lot to the table.

He doesn’t hit for average (.231 career clip) and he often struggles to reach base, which has led to a below-average OPS+ in four of his eight seasons.

He’s also a net negative defensively with a -2.5 career defensive WAR.

Joc Pederson… overrated?

— TiltedFrank (@VGo07) August 14, 2020

Pederson is a free agent after this year and the Cubs are struggling to stay afloat thus far, so we could see him moved at the trade deadline.

 

2. Brandon Crawford

Brandon Crawford has spent his entire 11-year MLB career with the San Francisco Giants.

The two parties have accomplished a lot together, winning World Series titles in 2012 and 2014 to cap off the Giants’ dominant dynasty run.

Crawford’s legacy has grown a lot as a result, but if you look at his individual performance on a year-by-year basis, it’s hard to justify the hype.

Crawford is a career .250 hitter with a .715 OPS who averages just 11 home runs a season.

He has a career OPS+ of 97 (which is three percent below league average) and has never finished a season with a traditional OPS higher than .782.

To be fair, Crawford is an outstanding defensive outfielder.

He is a three-time Gold Glover and has had two seasons with a defensive WAR above 3.0.

But on the whole, Crawford isn’t the player that many fans like to think he is.

 

1. Eric Hosmer

Eric Hosmer is unequivocally the most overrated player in baseball.

The 31-year-old is currently in the second season of an eight-year, $144 million deal with the San Diego Padres.

He’s certainly an important part of that club’s success, but he’s worth nowhere near that amount of money and he’s also regarded by many fans as a superstar-caliber player, which he is not.

Over his 11 years in MLB, Hosmer has compiled a .278 average and .770 OPS.

In seven of Hosmer’s seasons, he’s posted an OPS below .800, a number which is typically the benchmark for a good offensive season.

He also averages just 16 home runs a year.

On defense, Hosmer is just as underwhelming.

He’s oddly a three-time Gold Glover, which doesn’t make a whole lot of sense considering he had a negative defensive WAR in each of those Gold Glove seasons.

The only positive defensive WAR season of Hosmer’s career came in the COVID-shortened 2020 season when he finished with a 0.1 defensive WAR.

Can we all agree that Eric Hosmer is very overrated

— M.A.K 🇺🇸🇯🇵⚾️ (@maktheknife2000) July 23, 2018

The goal here is not to rag on Hosmer, who is a serviceable MLB player, but there is no denying that he is very overrated.

    Get ALL the latest MLB news straight to your inbox! Subscribe to the Cold Wire MLB newsletter here!    

Filed Under: MLB Tagged With: MLB

About Sam Leweck

Sam Leweck is a New Hampshire native and lifelong sports fan. He has several years of experience covering baseball as a writer, editor and broadcaster.

Suggest a correction

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Follow The Cold Wire!

More MLB News

Former Minnesota Twins Joe Mauer waves to the fans prior to game three of the American League Division Series between the New York Yankees and the Minnesota Twins at Target Field on October 07, 2019 in Minneapolis, Minnesota.

Graphic Reveals Potential 2024 MLB Hall Of Fame Class

1 hour ago

Former Denver Broncos NFL quarterback Peyton Manning delivers the first pitch as former Colorado Rockies first baseman Todd Helton looks on prior to the 91st MLB All-Star Game at Coors Field on July 13, 2021 in Denver, Colorado.

MLB Analyst Criticizes HOF For Snubbing Todd Helton

1 hour ago

Tommy Edman #19 of the St. Louis Cardinals celebrates after scoring on a RBI single in the third inning against the Pittsburgh Pirates during the game at PNC Park on October 5, 2022 in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania.

Cardinals Analyst Reminds Fans Baseball Is Nearly Back

1 hour ago

Ken Giles #58 of the Seattle Mariners is helped by medical staff during the seventh inning against the Toronto Blue Jays at T-Mobile Park on July 08, 2022.

An MLB Pitcher Is Attempting A Comeback

1 hour ago

A bucket with MLB baseballs on the field before a baseball game between Baltimore Orioles and the Tampa Bay Rays on August 2, 2020 at Oriole Park at Camden Yards in Baltimore, Maryland.

MLB Insider Reminds Fans Of Important Youth Sports Fact

2 hours ago

Marcus Stroman #0 of the Chicago Cubs reacts against the St. Louis Cardinals during the fifth inning at Wrigley Field on August 25, 2022 in Chicago, Illinois.

Marcus Stroman Applauds Ronald Acuna Jr. For A Celebration

2 hours ago

A baseball with MLB logo is seen at Citizens Bank Park before a game between the Washington Nationals and Philadelphia Phillies on June 28, 2018 in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania.

Scott Rolen Finds Himself In More Elite Company

2 hours ago

Former Texas Rangers' third baseman Adrian Beltre speaks at a ceremony to retire his jersey number before a game against the Oakland Athletics at Globe Life Park in Arlington on June 8, 2019 in Arlington, Texas.

Adrian Beltre Is Awaiting His Own Debate In 2024

2 hours ago

Mike Clevinger #52 of the San Diego Padres delivers a pitch against the Detroit Tigers during the bottom of the first inning at Comerica Park on July 26, 2022 in Detroit, Michigan.

White Sox Insider Weighs In On The Mike Clevinger Controversy

2 hours ago

Former Colorado Rockie Todd Helton and former NFL quarterback Peyton Manning take the field for the ceremonial first pitch ahead of the 91st MLB All-Star Game at Coors Field on July 13, 2021 in Denver, Colorado.

MLB Insider Remembers A Unique Todd Helton Play

2 hours ago

A detail of the MLB logo on a pair of pants during batting practice for the 88th MLB All-Star Game at Marlins Park on July 11, 2017 in Miami, Florida.

Scott Rolen Provides Hope For Players Buried On Hall Of Fame Ballot

2 hours ago

Bryson Stott #5 of the Philadelphia Phillies is congratulated at the dugout after scoring a run during the fourth inning against the San Diego Padres in game three of the National League Championship Series at Citizens Bank Park on October 21, 2022 in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania.

Phillies Manager Gives Fans The Ultimate Credit

2 hours ago

Former Houston Astros players Jeff Kent and Jose Cruz react after the ceremonial first pitch before Game Five of the American League Championship Series between the Boston Red Sox and the Houston Astros at Minute Maid Park on October 18, 2018 in Houston, Texas.

A Jeff Kent Stat Proves He Is Being Snubbed

2 hours ago

Adam Wainwright #50 of the St. Louis Cardinals walk to the dugout after being pulled from the game in the sixth inning against the Los Angeles Dodgers during the National League Wild Card Game at Dodger Stadium on October 06, 2021 in Los Angeles, California.

Adam Wainwright Congratulates Former Teammate On HOF

2 hours ago

A detail of a Boston Red Sox hat in the dugout during the first inning of the game against the San Francisco Giants at Fenway Park on July 19, 2016 in Boston, Massachusetts.

MLB Analysts Discuss Red Sox Shortstop Options

3 hours ago

A baseball with MLB logo is seen at Citizens Bank Park before a game between the Washington Nationals and Philadelphia Phillies on June 28, 2018 in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania.

Billy Wagner Compares Well Against A Fellow MLB Legend

3 hours ago

Mike Clevinger #52 of the San Diego Padres pitches against the Colorado Rockies in the second inning of a game at Coors Field on September 25, 2022 in Denver, Colorado.

MLB Insider Comments On The Mike Clevinger Situation

4 hours ago

Eddie Perez and former Atlanta Braves player Andruw Jones laugh after throwing out the first pitch prior to Game One of the National League Championship Series against the Los Angeles Dodgers at Truist Park on October 16, 2021 in Atlanta, Georgia.

Andruw Jones Has A Clear Hall Of Fame Case

4 hours ago

Billy Wagner asks Roberto Osuna #54 of the Houston Astros to sign a ball after throwing out the first pitch before Game 2 of the ALDS against the Tampa Bay Rays at Minute Maid Park on October 05, 2019 in Houston, Texas.

Billy Wagner Reacts To His Jump In HOF Voting

4 hours ago

Former Colorado Rockies player Todd Helton and Denver Bronco's player Von Miller after the MLB All-Star Celebrity Softball Game at Coors Field on July 11, 2021 in Denver, Colorado.

Graphic Shows MLB Legends Who Just Missed Cooperstown In 2023

6 hours ago

Jesus Aguilar #99 of the Miami Marlins hits a double in the third inning against the San Diego Padres at loanDepot park on August 16, 2022 in Miami, Florida.

MLB Insider Breaks Down A's Recent Signing

6 hours ago

A Houston Astros hat and glove are seen in the dugout during the fourth inning in game three of the American League Championship Series against the New York Yankees at Yankee Stadium on October 22, 2022 in New York City.

MLB Insider Reveals Intriguing Astros GM Candidate

7 hours ago

Billy Wagner throws out the first pitch before Game 2 of the ALDS between the Tampa Bay Rays and the Houston Astros at Minute Maid Park on October 05, 2019 in Houston, Texas.

Billy Wagner Is Gaining Traction In Hall Of Fame Voting

7 hours ago

Carlos Beltran talks to the media after being introduced by as the manager of the New York Mets during a press conference at Citi Field on November 4, 2019 in New York City.

Carlos Beltran Stood Out Among First-Timers On The Ballot

7 hours ago

Primary Sidebar

Search The Cold Wire

Footer

Privacy Policy

Terms and Conditions

Editorial Guidelines

Contact Us

Sitemap

Advertise

Follow us on

Copyright © 2023  ColdWireMedia · ALL RIGHTS RESERVED ·TheColdWire.com

Suggest a Correction

Ranking The Top 3 Most Overrated Players In MLB

1000 characters remaining