The Pittsburgh Steelers find themselves at the center of heated debate following their acquisition of Aaron Rodgers.
While some view the veteran quarterback as a potential solution, a growing chorus of analysts believes this move could derail what has been a remarkably consistent franchise under Mike Tomlin.
Recently, Fox Sports’ Colin Cowherd emerged as one of the most vocal critics of the decision.
“Quarterbacks can be a lot of things in the NFL…. But they can’t be weird… Weird doesn’t work because weird is unpredictable, and you want your coach to be predictable, and your quarterback, even if he’s limited, even if he’s unathletic, even if he’s small, even if he’s old. You want to know what you’re getting on Sunday and in camp, and at halftime. And with Aaron, because the NFL is unpredictable… you’re not sure what you get with Aaron,” Cowherd said on “The Herd.”
"Weird doesn't work… You're not sure what you get with Aaron."@ColinCowherd says Aaron Rodgers' star power isn't what it used to be. pic.twitter.com/0D6VtFgK4n
— Herd w/Colin Cowherd (@TheHerd) June 9, 2025
The criticism extends beyond Cowherd’s assessment. Multiple teams had opportunities to acquire Rodgers but walked away despite his proven talent.
The Los Angeles Rams declined his offer to play at a significant discount, with Sean McVay showing no interest.
The Minnesota Vikings received overtures from Rodgers, yet Kevin O’Connell wanted nothing to do with the veteran.
Even the New York Jets, desperate for quarterback stability, couldn’t move past what sources described as a bizarre introductory process.
Teams consistently prioritized locker room chemistry over raw talent when evaluating Rodgers.
The concerns center around Rodgers’ off-field behavior rather than his arm strength.
Professional football demands structure and predictability. Teams need to know exactly what they’re getting from their signal caller, especially during high-pressure moments.
Rodgers represents the antithesis of that stability, leaving organizations questioning which version of the quarterback will show up when adversity strikes.
NEXT: Former Player Raises A Big Question About Steelers' QB Situation
